Skip to main content
Saturday, 21 November 2026
New Delhi, India Public Interest • Evidence-Based • Accountable

Calcutta High Court Questions Abhishek Banerjee’s Allegations of Judicial

Calcutta High Court questions Abhishek Banerjee over judicial-bias allegations as Justice Krishna Rao asks him to identify the judges he accused.

Calcutta High Court Questions Abhishek Banerjee’s Allegations of Judicial

Name the Judges’: Calcutta High Court Puts Abhishek Banerjee on the Spot Over His Allegations of Judicial Bias

Justice Krishna Rao's pointed question to the TMC MP's lawyer has brought fresh attention to the debate over political allegations against the judiciary. The court made it clear that serious accusations must be backed by evidence, not merely political statements.

KOLKATA: Political leaders are accustomed to questioning their opponents, criticising governments and challenging decisions they disagree with. But when those accusations extend to the judiciary, the stakes are considerably higher.

Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Abhishek Banerjee received a pointed reminder of this during a hearing at the Calcutta High Court on November 12, when Justice Krishna Rao questioned his allegations of political influence within the judiciary.

The exchange was brief, but the judge's response was difficult to miss.

Addressing Banerjee's lawyer, Justice Rao remarked:

"Since he is so intelligent, let him give a list. I will see."

The judge was responding to allegations that some judges were politically aligned with the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). He also questioned whether Banerjee was effectively writing the Annual Confidential Reports (ACRs) of judges through his public statements.

The exchange was reported by Bar and Bench and The Telegraph.

How the Controversy Reached the Court

The remarks came during a hearing on Banerjee's petition challenging the West Bengal government's decision to downgrade his security cover from Z-plus to X category.

The matter took an unexpected turn when the state's Additional Advocate General, Billwadal Bhattacharya, raised Banerjee's recent televised interview before the court.

In the interview, Banerjee had reportedly accused a section of the judiciary of being influenced by the BJP. He also questioned the handling of his security-related petition and expressed dissatisfaction with the response to the threats he claimed to have faced.

The state government's counsel argued that such remarks amounted to an attack on the judiciary and urged the court to consider initiating criminal contempt proceedings against the TMC leader.

According to The New Indian Express, the state also placed a transcript and video recording of the interview before the court.

Justice Krishna Rao's Question Was Straightforward

Justice Rao questioned the basis on which Banerjee had made allegations about judges' political affiliations.

The judge's response was particularly pointed because Banerjee is not an ordinary political commentator. He is a sitting Member of Parliament and holds a position that carries considerable public responsibility.

The bench observed that an elected representative and an educated person could not simply be treated as an ordinary layperson when making such serious statements.

Justice Rao also suggested that if Banerjee was dissatisfied with an earlier judicial order, he could approach another bench or even the Supreme Court through the appropriate legal process.

The court's message was clear: disagreement with a judicial decision does not automatically establish political interference.

Also Read: Central Government Jobs November 2026: 198 Vacancies, Apply Online

Banerjee's Defence: A Matter of Security

Banerjee's lawyer, senior advocate Shoeb Alam, sought to explain the remarks in the context of the security concerns faced by the TMC MP and his family.

The lawyer argued that Banerjee had been expressing frustration after alleged attacks and repeated attempts to obtain adequate protection from the authorities.

He also told the court that his client had faced six attacks and that the state's assessment of his security requirements did not reflect the situation on the ground.

The petition sought protection under Article 21 of the Constitution, which guarantees the right to life and personal liberty.

However, Justice Rao made an important distinction. He clarified that the controversy surrounding Banerjee's public remarks would not affect the court's consideration of his security petition.

The judge observed that the petition would be decided on its own merits and that the allegations raised during the hearing would not be allowed to derail the proceedings.

The court subsequently reserved its order on the security petition, according to PTI's report published by The Week.

Criticising the Judiciary Is One Thing. Making Allegations Is Another.

There is nothing wrong with questioning the judiciary. In a democracy, every constitutional institution must remain open to scrutiny. Judges can be questioned, judgments can be criticised and legal decisions can be challenged.

But there is a difference between disagreeing with a judgment and suggesting that judges are working for a particular political party.

The latter is a serious allegation. It deserves more than a television interview or a political statement; it requires evidence.

This is where Banerjee's remarks invite an uncomfortable question. If he genuinely believes that judges are politically compromised, why not identify the individuals and present whatever evidence he claims to possess through the appropriate legal channels?

Public confidence in the judiciary cannot be treated casually. Nor should allegations against judges become another instrument in the daily exchange of political accusations.

And perhaps the most important lesson for Abhishek Banerjee is this: being a powerful politician does not put anyone above the responsibility of proving what they say. A parliamentary seat may give someone a voice, but it does not turn an allegation into evidence.

The judiciary does not need political certificates of loyalty, and politicians should not hand them out either.

Join the Conversation